A business owner put the question to me in these terms: "I have a €15,000 quote for a custom tool, and opposite it a subscription at €300 a month. The choice is quickly made, isn't it?" No, precisely. The right way to ask the question is: SaaS or custom, cost over 5 years? Because as long as no duration is fixed, you are comparing a rent to a purchase, and that kind of comparison always favours the rent.
This article does the calculation in front of you. With the assumptions written down, so you can replace mine with yours. At the end, you will have a five-row table and a decision grid. Not a ready-made conclusion: depending on your figures, the answer tips one way or the other.
The reflex that distorts everything: comparing a monthly amount to a one-off amount
€300 a month is the price of a photocopier. It goes through as a running expense, nobody convenes a committee. €15,000 is a line in the investment plan, a discussion with the accountant, a signature.
The two amounts do not live in the same accounting world, and that is exactly what blurs the decision. One is invisible, the other is visible. But invisible does not mean small.
To compare honestly, you need three things:
- A duration. Five years is the reasonable lifespan of an internal management tool. Below that, a development is poorly amortised. Above, the assumptions become fiction.
- A usage trajectory. How many users today, how many in three years?
- The cost of what the tool does not do. This is the line everyone forgets, and it is often the heaviest.
If you have not yet settled the underlying question (standard or specific), the full reasoning is in our article Build or buy software: how to decide. Here, we do not reopen the debate: we get out the calculator.
The SaaS calculation over 5 years: rarely €300 for 60 months
Take a subscription at €300 a month. The back-of-the-envelope calculation gives 300 × 60 = €18,000. Already above the custom quote, which often surprises people. But that figure assumes nothing moves for five years. In the real life of an SME, three things move.
The number of seats. Almost all subscription software is billed per user. You hire, you pay. One more salesperson is one more line, every month, forever.
The feature tier. You start on the entry-level plan. After 18 months, you are missing team-level permissions, or automatic reminders, or the accounting export. Those functions are in the higher plan. The price per user goes from €30 to €45, for everyone at once.
Indexation. Vendors revise their prices. It is not dishonest, it is their model. But over five years, a modest annual revision adds up.
Let us set out three scenarios, assumptions visible.
Scenario A: stable usage
10 users at €30, no hiring, no change of plan, no indexation. That is €3,600 a year.
5-year total: €18,000.
Scenario B: gentle growth
10 users to start with, 2 more each year, price frozen at €30.
| Year | Users | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 10 | €3,600 |
| 2 | 12 | €4,320 |
| 3 | 14 | €5,040 |
| 4 | 16 | €5,760 |
| 5 | 18 | €6,480 |
5-year total: €25,200.
Scenario C: growth, tier and extras
Same hiring, plus: €1,500 of configuration and data migration in year 1, a bridge to your invoicing tool at €80 a month from year 2, a move to the higher tier (€45 per user) in year 3, and a price revision of 5% a year.
| Year | Detail | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 10 users at €30 + set-up | €5,100 |
| 2 | 12 users at €31.50 + bridge | €5,496 |
| 3 | 14 users at €45 + bridge | €8,520 |
| 4 | 16 users at €47.25 + bridge | €10,032 |
| 5 | 18 users at €49.61 + bridge | €11,676 |
5-year total: €40,824.
Between scenario A and scenario C, the gap is €22,824. That is not a modelling detail: it is the difference between "the subscription is the obvious choice" and "the subscription is the department's most expensive item". And neither of the two is fanciful.
The custom calculation over 5 years: the quote is not the cost
Symmetrically, €15,000 is not the total cost of a tool built for you. Software lives. It has to be hosted, monitored, fixed when something breaks, and adapted when the business changes.
The items to budget for, over five years:
- The initial build. The quote. For ranges by size of perimeter, see how much custom software costs.
- Hosting and monitoring. A modest but real monthly cost.
- Maintenance. Fixes, security updates, user support.
- Changes. Over five years, expect one or two significant requests. A new type of contract, a regulatory obligation, a second branch to integrate.
At Magram, maintenance and changes go through a monthly support plan, from €100 to €650 excl. VAT a month depending on the perimeter, and around €200 excl. VAT a month on average for an internal application with 10 to 30 users. It includes hosting, backup monitoring, security updates and a monthly allowance of time for fixes and small adjustments. Larger changes are quoted separately.
In the meantime, let us set explicit working assumptions, to be replaced by the lines of your own quote: €720 a year for hosting, €1,800 a year for maintenance from year 2, one change at €3,000 in year 3 and a second at €2,500 in year 5.
| Year | Detail | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Build + hosting | €15,720 |
| 2 | Hosting + maintenance | €2,520 |
| 3 | + change | €5,520 |
| 4 | Hosting + maintenance | €2,520 |
| 5 | + change | €5,020 |
5-year total: €31,300.
The comparison table, cumulative
The decision shows up in the cumulative view. Here are the four trajectories side by side.
| End of year | SaaS A (stable) | SaaS B (growth) | SaaS C (growth + tier) | Custom |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | €3,600 | €3,600 | €5,100 | €15,720 |
| 2 | €7,200 | €7,920 | €10,596 | €18,240 |
| 3 | €10,800 | €12,960 | €19,116 | €23,760 |
| 4 | €14,400 | €18,720 | €29,148 | €26,280 |
| 5 | €18,000 | €25,200 | €40,824 | €31,300 |
Reading: with stable usage or gentle growth, the subscription stays cheaper over five years. Against scenario C, custom pulls ahead during the fourth year.
In other words, there is no general answer. There is a tipping point, and it depends on three variables you know better than any comparison site.
What really tips the decision
The number of users
This is the most brutal variable. A subscription costs per seat: its price grows with your company. A tool built for you costs per functional perimeter: opening five more accounts changes nothing on the bill.
At ten users, the subscription is comfortable. At forty, the line becomes a board-level topic. If your user base is going to double in three years, redo the table with that assumption before you sign.
The expected lifespan of the tool
A need that will disappear in eighteen months (an exceptional project, an activity on trial) never justifies a development. A process that has been at the heart of your business for fifteen years and will still be there in ten justifies amortising it.
Ask yourself frankly: will I still see this tool running in 2032?
The gap between what the software does and what you need
This is the invisible item, and often the heaviest. When the market tool covers 70% of the need, the remaining 30% does not disappear. It becomes human time: an export to a spreadsheet, a double entry, a shared file someone updates on Friday, a manual check before invoicing.
Do the calculation with your own figures. Two people, three hours a week, forty-five weeks a year, at a loaded cost of €35 an hour: that is about €9,450 a year. Over five years, it is more than €47,000, more than the development quote and the base subscription combined. Those hours appear on no quote, in no comparison, and yet they are the main reason teams end up rebuilding in a spreadsheet what the software was supposed to do. We detailed this mechanism in your software works, but your teams still work in Excel.
What cannot be priced but weighs
- Reversibility. If the vendor raises its prices by 30% or closes a function, what do you do? Changing tool is counted in months.
- Ownership. A tool built for you stays yours. You can hand its future over to someone else.
- Dependence on the builder. Symmetrical and real. A development with no documentation and no access to the code is another kind of prison.
- Lead time. A subscription is activated in a day. A build takes weeks. The time during which the problem keeps costing money counts too.
When the subscription wins, and it often does
Let us be clear, because we build custom tools and it would be too convenient to conclude otherwise.
The subscription wins when:
- the need is standard (accounting, payroll, email, electronic signature, simple sales tracking);
- the users are few and will stay so;
- the function is not a differentiator: you do not win business because you handle expense reports differently from your competitors;
- the tool must be in service next week.
In those cases, custom development costs more over five years, and it takes your time as an owner for zero gain. Pay the subscription, and get on with something else.
Custom is justified in the opposite case: when your way of working is precisely what makes your value, when no market software fits without contortions, and when the number of users makes the per-seat bill painful. For a concrete, costed case, see our comparison of CRM pricing under both models.
How to do the calculation at your company, in an hour
- List the real users, today and in three years. Not the licences bought: the people who open the tool every week.
- Take your latest subscription invoice and look for the extra lines: connectors, storage, premium support, inactive seats.
- Put a figure on the time spent on workarounds. Ask two people to note, for a week, the time spent re-keying, exporting and checking.
- Ask for a quote with the recurring costs included. A development quote without a maintenance line is an incomplete quote.
- Fill in the five-row table with your assumptions, and see where the curves cross.
If the crossing comes after the fifth year, keep the subscription. If it comes in year three, the question deserves a real discussion.
In summary
The debate of SaaS or custom over a 5-year horizon is not settled with two numbers, but with a trajectory. A subscription at €300 a month represents between €18,000 and more than €40,000 over five years, depending on what happens to your headcount and the vendor's prices. A €15,000 development represents €31,300 once hosting, maintenance and two changes are included.
The variable that decides, in nine cases out of ten, is neither of the two: it is the cost of the hours spent compensating for what the tool does not do.
The K.O. Diagnostic starts with a two-minute online questionnaire, followed by a 30-minute conversation about your organisation and your tools. It is free and without obligation, and you leave with your main bottleneck identified and a first costed estimate.
If you want to apply this calculation to your exact case, with your figures and no obligation, let us talk. We will also tell you, when that is the case, that the subscription remains the right answer.
A question about your situation?
Ask Quentin, he replies personally.
